
48 Hours: Hard Evidence
2005–2016 · TLC · 60 min · 2 seasons
S11E41 · Playing by the Rules?
Sun, 17 Apr, 12:00 pm
In 2015, attorneys for David Temple were appealing his 2007 conviction for the murder of his wife with evidence that then prosecutor Kelly Siegler didn't share with the defense and information on another possible suspect. But will they be able to win?
About
48 Hours: Hard Evidence is a version of the award-winning CBS true-crime series delves into investigations of murder, gambling, missing persons and other incidents, with 48 Hours correspondent Maureen Maher introducing reports.
Episodes
- E01
Power and Passion
Fri, 9 Jan· 60 min - E21
The Blue River Murder
Fri, 16 Oct· 60 minDetectives find evidence of domestic abuse while recovering clues from a woman's body in Colorado's Blue River.
- E22
The Last Confession
Fri, 16 Oct· 60 minAlthough investigators believe they know who killed Irene Garza, they have no hard evidence or witnesses.
- E23
Reasonable Doubt
Tue, 9 Feb· 60 minA jury must decide whether Brian Eftenoff is guilty of murdering his wife, Judi, after she dies of a cocaine overdose.
- E24
Who Killed the Prosecutor
Tue, 9 Feb· 60 minWhen Assistant District Attorney Steve Tauzer is found brutally stabbed to death in his garage, a former colleague and friend becomes a chief suspect.
- E25
The Sugar Land Conspiracy
Tue, 9 Feb· 60 minIn Sugar Land, Texas, two members of the Whitaker family are shot dead by a masked intruder; two members survive the ambush; police believe the family interrupted a burglary, until they uncover a conspiracy involving one of the family members.
- E26
Star Witness
Tue, 23 Feb· 60 minBecause of false testimonies, two people are imprisoned for murders they didn't commit; Gloria Killian is convicted of masterminding a robbery-homicide, while Clarence Elkins receives life for rape and murder.
- E27
Deadly Prophecy
Tue, 23 Feb· 60 minDevout Mormon Faylene Grant records having visions of her imminent death; her husband, Doug, then finds her lifeless body in the bathtub of their home.
- E28
Justice for Sheila
Tue, 23 Feb· 60 minWhen Sheila Bellush is shot to death, police suspect she is the victim of a murder-for-hire plot orchestrated by her ex-husband, Allen Blackthorne.
- E29
Deadly Proposal
Tue, 1 Mar· 60 min - E30
Millionaire Manhunt
Tue, 1 Mar· 60 min - E31
Secrets of Palm Beach
Tue, 1 Mar· 60 min - E32
By Two and Two
Tue, 15 Mar· 60 minTwins Betty and Peggy are both accused of hiring a hit man to kill Betty's husband; one twin is found guilty following the hit man's shaky testimony, while the other is let off.
- E33
Decades of Deceit
Tue, 15 Mar· 60 minMore familiar with liquor-law violations than violent crimes, a detective joins the cold-case squad and investigates the 20-year-old murder of Amy Weidner.
- E34
Memory of Murder
Tue, 15 Mar· 60 minJoan Porco recants after indicating that her son, Christopher, is responsible for the savage attack with an ax that claimed her husband's life, and she begs investigators to leave Christopher alone.
- E35
The Law & Mrs. Shelton
Tue, 22 Mar· 60 minAttorney Catherine Shelton leads a storied life which includes several run-ins with the law, then she becomes mired in an investigation that results in the conviction of her husband for murder.
- E36
What She Did for Love
Tue, 22 Mar· 60 minCarlo Ventre violates a custody agreement with his former partner, Toni Dykstra, when he takes their baby daughter to Italy, but what begins as a case of international parental kidnapping ends with a tragic death.
- E37
Deadly Voyage
Tue, 22 Mar· 60 minAfter aspiring actress Ashley Barnett dies while on a three-day party cruise, her mother searches for answers; George Smith disappears on his honeymoon cruise.
- E38
The Boy Next Door
Sun, 3 Apr· 60 minIn 1993, 18-year old Tricia Pacaccio was stabbed to death. Neighbor Michael Gargiulo was an early suspect, but there wasn't enough evidence to arrest him. Garguilo fled to California where his appetite for murder grew. Maureen Maher has the story.
- E39
Double Jeopardy
Sun, 3 Apr· 60 minIn 1988, Mel Ignatow sexually tortured and murdered Brenda Schaefer. After a jury acquitted Ignatow, photos of the torture emerged. But the U.S. Constitution states a person can't be tried twice for the same offense. Erin Moriarty has the story.
- E40
Secrets in the Sand
Sun, 17 Apr· 60 minThree years after April and Justin Barber wed; they were shot while walking on a deserted Florida beach. April was killed and Justin was shot four times, but survived. He said it was a robbery gone wrong, but police disagreed. Harold Dow reports.
- E41
Playing by the Rules?
Sun, 17 Apr· 60 minIn 2015, attorneys for David Temple were appealing his 2007 conviction for the murder of his wife with evidence that then prosecutor Kelly Siegler didn't share with the defense and information on another possible suspect. But will they be able to win?
Cast

Maureen Maher
Host